Choose Your Own Pie 2 Pack

That’s right, double your fun by adding a second pie to your order to ship in the same box. Choose any two of our award winning pies; perhaps two of our signature Chicken Pies for the upcoming family gathering, or a savory pie and a sweet pie for a complete family meal featuring dinner and dessert.

$99

That’s right, double your fun by adding a second pie to your order to ship in the same box. Choose any two of our award winning pies; perhaps two of our signature Chicken Pies for the upcoming family gathering, or a savory pie and a sweet pie for a complete family meal featuring dinner and dessert.

More Details

Each Pie is approximately 9" in diameter and serves 6-8 people
Choose from the below options:

  • Our Signature Chicken Pie – the one that Oprah made the most famous pie in America
  • Shepherd’s Pie – a Cape Cod favorite featuring ground beef sauteed with onions, corn, creamy buttery mashed potatoes and cheese
  • Apple Pie – hand peeled apples coated in cinnamon, sugar and nutmeg
  • Cherry Pie – filled with tart cherry pie filling
  • Buffalo Chicken – stuffed with slow-cooked, hand-pulled chicken and buffalo sauce.
  • BBQ Pulled Pork Pie – slow-roasted pork simmered in sweet barbecue sauce.
  • Spinach & Feta Pie – vegetarian’s delight. Centerville Pie’s version of the traditional Spanakopita.
  • Lemon Pie – full of bright zesty lemon filling encrusted in our signature flaky crust.

Use And Care

Pies are unbaked and each box is carefully packed with dry ice and picked up for immediate shipment.

Delivery Options

Custom Orders

Need to modify this item or place a corporate order? Contact us.

Shipping Details

  • Items are prepared fresh and shipped directly from the shop
  • Centerville Pie Co. ships Monday-Wednesday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
This item has FREE Shipping